After months of staunchly maintaining his innocence former Heart of
the City chief executive Alex Swney phoned his parents on Tuesday night
to say he was going to plead guilty to nearly $1.8 million worth of tax
Swney, who once challenged John Banks in the Auckland
mayoralty race, appeared in court yesterday for what was expected to be
an administrative hearing looking ahead to trial. However, he entered a
surprise guilty plea that leaves him facing up to five years in jail
and/or a fine of up to $50,000.
Alex Swney refused to comment on yesterday’s court proceedings. Picture / Janna Dixon
The 57-year-old pleaded guilty
after the 39 charges laid by the IRD were condensed to four
representative counts during what was meant to be an administration
hearing. When contacted on Tuesday, Swney said he wasn’t sure what was
happening in court the following day.
Swney, who left Auckland
District Court by the back door, wouldn’t comment last night. But his
Morrinsville-based father Gordon Swney told the Herald it was good to
get the court process over with, rather than letting it drag on.
“We were right up with the play on [the guilty plea], he told
us last night [Tuesday]… We knew that was going to be the strategy.”
Asked how he felt about his son’s admission of guilt, he replied: “How
would you feel if it was one of yours?”
Gordon Swney said the
Morrinsville community had been very supportive of his family, and his
son also had a network of sympathetic people.
“He’s contributed a lot to the city. He’s a passionate man about the city, and it’s just unfortunate the way it’s unfolded.”
He would not say whether he thought his son’s tax evasion was a mistake, but he said he was still proud to be Swney’s father.
Grant Fraser yesterday bailed Swney to the Grey Lynn address – a
spacious, open-plan, modern property on the edge of Ponsonby Rd, where
the entrepreneur lives with his wife Ange, the owner of a boutique
shoeshop, and their two daughters.
Judge Fraser ordered Swney to surrender his passport, despite defence counsel Murray Gibson saying he was “not a flight risk”.
judge ordered a pre-sentence report without considering home detention
and indicated a term of imprisonment was the only viable outcome at
sentencing in April.
Swney staunchly maintained his innocence
last year but that changed when the case was pushed forward with new
lawyer Murray Gibson and a fresh Crown prosecutor taking over the file.
of the City – a city centre business association registered by Swney in
1994 – has income-tax exemption on the basis that it was created to
develop or increase amenities for the Auckland public.
amended charges cover personal tax evasion of $1,757,147 over 12 years
to July 2012. Court documents stated Swney did not provide tax forms or
returns over extended periods “and did so intending to evade the
assessment of tax”.
The charges also outlined how he committed
the offending while acting as an independent contractor to Heart of the
City, while sole director of his own company AGS Services Limited.
He provided “taxable supplies” but did not register for GST or provide any returns.
including Heart of the City, have taken steps to protect their position
in the wake of Swney’s downfall. AGS Services was placed into
liquidation on November 14.
Liquidators Colin McCloy and Craig
Sanson said in their first report that Swney “was using the company to
invoice for the provision of personal consultancy services he provided”
to Heart of the City.
McCloy and Sanson’s report said they would
conduct a thorough investigation of his actions, but noted all
communication with him was being conducted through lawyers.
month, Heart of the City’s board announced it had launched civil
proceedings against Swney and because of that, refused to comment on
The organisation confirmed an
independent investigation had been completed by McGrathNicol and civil
proceedings had been launched as a result.
Chairman Terry Gould said they had also obtained interim asset freezing and disclosure orders from the court.
of the City had its annual meeting at the end of October at which Mr
Gould told stakeholders he was in close communication with the Serious
Yesterday, the office confirmed it was investigating Swney but would not go into further detail.
of the City, which collaborated on the Auckland Tourism, Events and
Economic Development-developed “The Show Never Stops” marketing campaign
and events like Artweek Auckland, last year received more than $4.2
million from Auckland Council, which came up with about 80 per cent of
the organisation’s funding. The council too refused to comment until
Swney had been sentenced.
According to QV, Swney jointly owns four properties around the upper North Island with a combined value of $3.82 million.
company, Crummer Rd Trustee Company Ltd, owns the house where he lives
which has a CV of $1.65 million, bringing the combined value of the
property portfolio up to $5.47 million.
How the case unfolded
February 21, 2014: IRD lays 39 charges against Swney alleging he knowingly avoided paying taxes.
April 15, 2014: Swney appears for the first time at Auckland District Court.
May 2, 2014: Judge Grant Fraser allows Swney interim name suppression to protect the defendant’s reputation and that of Heart of the City
Oct 5, 2014: Swney’s name suppression lapses as he pleads not guilty to all charges
Jan 28, 2015: Swney pleads guilty to four amended charges and is told he will face a jail term
April 30, 2015: Swney will face a maximum sentence of 5 years imprisonment and/or a $50,000 fine